Entry 111 — Certainties

I think recently I wrote of the impossibility of knowing a true absolute.  It would require omniscience to do so, I believe.  But that does not mean there are no true absolutes.

Just now, I realized that we can know a true absolute.  When?  Sorry for the anti-climax, but it’s when we have defined absolutes into a system.  One such system would be mathematics.  If a equals 5 and b equals 7, then it is an absolute certainty that the sum of a and b is 12.  Syllogisms yield absolute truths as well in a similar way.  If all men can reason and Joe is a man, it is an absolute certainty that Joe is a man.  Or: it is absolutely certain that something said to fit a definition fits that definition.

In any event, I now decree a new hierarchy of certainties, listed here from most to least certain:

1. Philosophical Certainty (we can’t know of any)

2. Mathematical Certainty (e.g., 5 times 3 is 15)

3. Scientific Certainty (e.g., gravity keeps the moon from escaping the solar system)

4. Historical Certainty (e.g., Shakespeare wrote the works attributed to him)

5. Everyday Certainty (e.g., I watched Joe and Bucky play Ed and Marty in tennis this morning)

Each of these is certain, but a small step less certain than the one listed above it.  Any of them may also be Philosophically Certain but we can never know if it is.

Have I now worked out something college freshmen are taught in Philosophy courses?  It does seems painfully obvious to me.  Yet I know that there are many who will find is too advanced to understand, including people who have taken more than an introductory college course in philosophy.

Leave a Reply